WZA111

That discrepancy

mc)

ttpd都可以用難聽去形容

jasonscy

真係要講句
可唔可以換左jack?

基本上某d歌一聽就知係佢手仲要係不停重複緊同一樣野

JasOh103

Taylor Swift真係每況愈下
又臃腫又重複又幼稚
係你係有talent但咁又點，talent can only take you so far
...
just11256 發表於 2024-4-19 13:29

But reputation has I Did Something Bad, Don’t Blame Me, Delicate, Getaway Car, King Of My Heart
MIDnights only has Snow On The Beach & YOYOK

JasOh103

如果佢冇出過midnights, 我會對呢隻碟既好感多好多
我覺得裡面既歌係好聽過上隻碟 但係Jack啲production重覆同低B搞到好反感…

TTPD > Midnights

聽埋下半隻先

just11256

But reputation has I Did Something Bad, Don’t Blame Me, Delicate, Getaway Car, King Of My Heart
MI ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-20 02:30

    Midnights頭六首都鍾意，有詞鋒亦有新鮮感嘅production
係後半有幾首太低B，3am edition啲歌都好

Reputation得Joe嗰啲冧歌ok，反kanye啲歌大部份實在太cringe太tryhard（雖然我睇完Eras Tour之後開始為LWYMMD平反）

今次完全唔知佢做緊乜，純粹複製以前嘅作品然後失敗

JasOh103

聽TTPD好笑既位係 咦 呢首唔錯wor -> 望下credit -> Dessner instead of Antonoff -> 唔怪得啦

Like:
1. The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived
2. Guilty as Sin?
3. Florida!!!
4. But Daddy I Love Him
5. The Alchemy
6. The Tortured Poets Department
7. loml

Meh:
1. Fortnight
2. So Long, London
3. Fresh Out The Slammer

Cringe:
1. My Boy Only Breaks His Favorite Toys
2. Down Bad
3. Who's Afraid of Little Old Me?
4. I Can Fix Him (No Really I Can)
5. I Can Do It With a Broken Heart
6. Clara Bow

WZA111

The Anthology is much better...

ifeinano

原來咁多人憎Jack Antonoff

musicsuperman

TTPD Pitchfork 6.6, Anthology 6.0

6.0 TAYTAY 音樂生涯最低分 LOL

bagfgfcde

TTPD Pitchfork 6.6, Anthology 6.0

6.0 TAYTAY 音樂生涯最低分 LOL
musicsuperman 發表於 2024-4-22 17:06

Good job Pitchfork
不枉我係忠實讀者

JasOh103

Updated ranking:
1. 1989 (stolen)
2. folklore
3. Fearless (TV)
4. Red (TV)
5. Lover
6. evermore
7. Speak Now (TV)
8. reputation
9. TTPD
10. MIDnights

全日狂loop Guilty As Sin? 同 But Daddy I Love Him

jasonscy

Updated ranking:
1. 1989 (stolen)
2. folklore
3. Fearless (TV)
4. Red (TV)
5. Lover
6. evermore
7. S ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-22 15:29

my ranking Top 1,2 same as you.

1989 stolen and folklore is classic and I think no more upcoming TS album can overtake this two album

WZA111

Guilty As Sin? is saving this album ngl...

mosesming

Good job Pitchfork
不枉我係忠實讀者
bagfgfcde 發表於 2024-4-22 19:10

    Peppa Pig隻碟都高分過佢

JasOh103

Guilty As Sin? is saving this album ngl...
WZA111 發表於 2024-4-23 12:46

因為呢首好有主角啲1975味

But daddy I love him都好好聽 完全唔覺係六分鐘
條女要發力寫都可以好正
loml嗰陣folkmore味都越煲越正

JasOh103

希望 @nicknicknick 出黎講兩句點睇呢隻碟 cuz it’s the only review that matters

HOTMAN

Updated ranking:
1. Folklore
2. Evermore
3. 1989(TV)
4. Reputation
5. MIDnights
6. Red (TV)
7. Speak Now (TV)
8. Lovers
9. TTPD
10. Fearless (TV)
11. Debut

JasOh103

Updated ranking:
10. Fearless (TV)
HOTMAN 發表於 2024-4-24 10:10

in ascending order?

Taytay did NOT write State Of Grace, Treacherous, ATW, I Almost Do, Sad Beautiful Tragic, Begin Again, Come Back Be Here, Better Man, Back to December, Enchanted to be humiliated by MIDnights like that...

HOTMAN

in ascending order?

Taytay did NOT write State Of Grace, Treacherous, ATW, I Almost Do, Sad Beauti ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-24 10:22

呢堆歌我只愛State Of Grace, ATW, I Almost Do, Begin Again, Back to December, Enchanted哦
但MIDnights最少我喜Lavender Haze, Maroon, Anti-hero, SOTB, Youre on your own kid, Midnight rain, Vigilante Shit, Bejewelled, Karma, Bigger than the whole sky哦

just11256

因為呢首好有主角啲1975味

But daddy I love him都好好聽 完全唔覺係六分鐘
條女要發力寫都可 ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-23 14:45

ha，今次啲六分鐘歌勁長勁拖，以前完全冇呢個問題，Enchanted/Dear John啲六分鐘功力完全冇晒
有啲歌唔知佢係咪聽咗A&W，要Jack玩半途轉structure，但轉得勁到喉唔到肺，好唔掂

loml係ok，回歸平淡咪幾好

JasOh103

ha，今次啲六分鐘歌勁長勁拖，以前完全冇呢個問題，Enchanted/Dear John啲六分鐘功力完全冇晒
有啲歌唔知 ...
just11256 發表於 2024-4-24 12:51

It’s ok, you’ll get the song soon

jasonscy

聽TTPD好笑既位係 咦 呢首唔錯wor -> 望下credit -> Dessner instead of Antonoff -> 唔怪得啦

Like:
1. T ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-20 01:35

聽左幾日 so far 鐘意

Fortnight
The Tortured Poets Department
Down Bad
So Long, London
But Daddy I Love Him
Florida !!!
Guilty as Sin?
loml
The Smallest Man Who Ever Lived

LoveMirkay520

芬蘭音樂都算係外語音樂之一...牙可？
Maustetytöt - Syntynyt suruun ja puettu pettymyksin
https://youtu.be/XgzKpRbvmww?si=AZlLo4hEdovTWMy9

jasonscy

聽左幾日 so far 鐘意

Fortnight
The Tortured Poets Department
Down Bad
So Long, London
But Daddy I ...
jasonscy 發表於 2024-4-24 15:39

Loml 正式成為呢隻碟 top1

bagfgfcde

Deeper Well track ranking:

1. The Architect
2. Heaven Is
3. Lonely Millionaire
4. Moving Out
5. Cardinal
6. Nothing to be Scared Of
7. Deeper Well
8. Dinner with Friends
9. Sway
10. Giver / Taker
11. Heart of the Wood
12. Anime Eyes
13. Too Good to be True
14. Jade Green

koko51018

有冇人鐘意 St.Vincent 隻新碟？

just11256

Dua隻碟⋯⋯單曲已經係最好嗰幾首

bagfgfcde

Dua隻碟⋯⋯單曲已經係最好嗰幾首
just11256 發表於 2024-5-4 04:39

見到連呢度都冇人討論就知係悶碟一隻
（好多人討論同鬧嗰隻就係爛碟）

musicsuperman

Dua Lipa新碟確實有啲悶，不過TAY TAY TTPD都一樣唔見得好
So far今年女歌手的碟覺得Beyonce同Ari既比較好

bagfgfcde

支持 Kendrick diss 爆 Drake

mosesming

支持 Kendrick diss 爆 Drake
bagfgfcde 發表於 2024-5-4 20:24

   公道講句Drake嗰幾首算OK
但佢挑緊嗰個叫Kendrick

bagfgfcde

公道講句Drake嗰幾首算OK
但佢挑緊嗰個叫Kendrick
mosesming 發表於 2024-5-6 14:59

The Heart Part 6 唔係好得 講自己多過 diss 翻人

JasOh103

Olivia開香港場 omg

lmml4

你哋準備好未？！Olivia Rodrigo即將聯同佢嘅GUTS world tour登陸香港！門票將於5月17號3pm正式公開發售！
GET READY. Olivia Rodrigo is heading your way on her GUTS world tour!
???????????????????????? ???????????????????????????? - ???????????????? ???????????????????? ???????????????? ???????? ???????????????? ????????????????
2024.9.24 (Tue) 8PM | ????AsiaWorld-Arena
Tickets and VIP details to be announced ✨
Tickets and VIP will be available on:
⁠ ▪️ Live Nation 會員優先訂票 Live Nation Members Pre-sale⁠
2024.5.16 (Thu) 3PM to 11:59PM
▪️ 公開發售 General Sale⁠
2024.5.17 (Fri) 3PM onwards at cityline.com

nicknicknick

希望 @nicknicknick 出黎講兩句點睇呢隻碟 cuz it’s the only review that matters  ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-4-24 09:13

    由Lover開始已經知道呢個女人啲碟唔可以一兩日就下定論
所以聽咗三個禮拜先9 up下

Fortnight - 佢近年揀嘅lead singles 都係 right choices   將最catchy嘅outro 交俾Post 唱思路正確
TTPD- 80s excellence
My fave only works with Jack Antonoff - 第一次聽聽到成頭問號 但係個腦成日會無啦啦響起My boy OnLy BrEaKs hIS FAvoRite To~~~OYYY~~yys a GROWER
Down Bad - so cool! 全碟最radio friendly 'fuck it if I can't have him' 應該可以總結佢半個寫歌生涯
So long, London - The National 借屍還魂 Aaron you will ALWAYS be famous
But Daddy I'm Gay - Fearless噶 Speak Now噶
Fresh out the slammer - 全碟最「Lana Del Rey cosplay」嘅歌  tempo changes我收貨
Florida!!! - 全碟最愛  雖然Florence一開口已經贏晒
GAS? - BOP! Downtown Lights - inspired songs always WIN (same for 神曲 Love It If We Made It )
WAOLOM - 支持Olivia Rodrigo 只有這句
I Can Fix Him - Vocal 是硬傷  但係作為下個1-2-3 punch 之前嘅過渡收貨
loml - Talent 又贏 只有這句
ICDIWABH - BOP! Bejewelled's prettier sister
The Smallest Man - 佢終於master到Mad Woman係要點寫
The Alchemy - 千千首鍊金術好聽啲
Clara Bow - 為自己加冕世代IT girl  one of her best closers

(Anthology 喜歡 So High School The Black Dog The Prophecy Peter Robin The Bolter )

整體黎講幾surprised佢會響第N個career's peak出一隻咁「壓抑」嘅碟 覺得呢隻碟更加值Midnights呢個title 冇好明顯嘅pop hook 應該可以洗走一大堆'Eras Tour' fans (Thank god!)
欣賞今次係佢生涯第一次探討「自毀（慰）」同埋toxic fandom嘅問題 佢亦有嘗試令自己嘅vocal聽落有變化（雖然成唔成功係另一回事 ）

但係Vocal依然係硬傷 如果啲歌交畀個Vocal好啲嘅歌手唱嘅話應該會少好多「點解首首歌都一樣架」嘅批評
歌詞方面希望呢位女士唔好再寫school/class/toy/queen     同埋folkmore 嘅成功真係令佢以為自己真係變咗poet  成日加啲thesaurus.com嘅字落啲歌詞度
有啲似DSE考生為咗攞5**狂加啲唔啱嘅context嘅字咁 佢嘅歌詞好嘅地方從來都唔係用詞有幾複雜
Production wise Jack Antonoff GET A JOB STAY AWAY FROM HER

總括嚟講就係Talent又贏 希望呢位女士繼續大破業界紀錄 演唱會繼續帶動經濟 繼續激死班haters

WZA111

由Lover開始已經知道呢個女人啲碟唔可以一兩日就下定論  
所以聽咗三個禮拜先9 up下

Fortni ...
nicknicknick 發表於 2024-5-10 22:12

歌詞嗰段笑死
Preach

JasOh103

由Lover開始已經知道呢個女人啲碟唔可以一兩日就下定論  
所以聽咗三個禮拜先9 up下

Fortni ...
nicknicknick 發表於 2024-5-10 22:12

好正
真愛
btw我一個月就已經聽TTPD多過MIDnights

Your review is so much more valid than Pitchfork’s
詞既部分實在講得太好
Toys同蛋餅都越聽越正 我覺得成隻碟到ICDIWABH都zero skips…(cuz I hate Bejeweled & this kind of production)

HOTMAN

Post Malone x Morgan Wallen 新歌好正

nicknicknick

好正
真愛
btw我一個月就已經聽TTPD多過MIDnights

Your review is so much more  ...
JasOh103 發表於 2024-5-10 22:55

   

但係都支持Pitchfork比6.6+6呢位邪教女士

Kfmusic

TTPD喜歡Fortnight,Down Bad, So long London, Florida!!! guilty as sin? loml Clara Bow
見到EU tour新rundown有But Daddy I Love Him之後，聽聽下又好似ok，諗起Love Story

Anthology喜歡The Black Dog, The bolter, I look in People’s windows
I hate it here好underrated!

JasOh103

Loml 正式成為呢隻碟 top1
jasonscy 發表於 2024-5-1 09:09

好好聽 one of her career best omg
This album’s champagne problems